Plain Talking Patient Survey Results
Introduction
All the results were manually loaded per practice on to Survey Monkey. This enabled full analysis of the data at both individual practice level and as a group.
- The total patient population across all six practices was 28,000
- 129 patients completed the survey, therefore exceeding the target of at least 2 responses per 1000 patients
Results
The results are detailed below for Plain Talking in four sections:
- Patient Demographics - This section gives details of the demographics, such as age, sex and ethnicity of the patients who completed the survey
- A&E Attendances - This section reports on recent attendances at A&E including ways of reducing activity
- Communication - This section looks into the ways in which patients and practices communicate and areas for improvement
- Other Comments - This section reviews other comments made by respondents
SECTION 1: Patient Demographics
Responses were received from all ages of patients. 30% of responders were aged 56 – 65 years, and in total 51.6 % were aged 56 to 75 years. This was as expected as this is the age group that have health problems and chronic illnesses and are therefore more likely to have concerns about the GP services available and so responded to the survey. It is felt to be representative of the age groups that use Primary Care services.
Overall 70% of the responders were female and 30% male, which reflects the findings of every day GP service.
The vast majority, 95%, of responders were British or mixed British. This reflects the population of this area in rural Wiltshire with the towns of Amesbury and Tidworth. The remaining 5% were Bangladeshi, Asian or Other Black. 1.6% did not state their ethnic group. 10% of responders stated that they were a carer for another person. This is high if correlated to the whole practice population, but not if correlated to the high female, and older age group that have completed this survey.
SECTION 2: A&E Attendance
The majority, 65%, of respondents, had not attended A&E in the last year. Of the remaining respondents, 41 had visited A&E once or twice in the last 12 months and three had been more than three times. The reasons for attendance were categorised as follows:
| | | | |
| | Reason | Number of patients attending A&E | |
| | Fracture | 15 | |
| | Pain not relieved by simple analgesia 8 | 8 | |
| | Loss of consciousness 1 | 1 | |
| | Severe chest pain 1 | 1 | |
| | breathing difficulties 2 | 2 | |
| | Severe bleeding 5 | 5 | |
| | Deep wounds 6 | 6 | |
| | Other (eye problems, infections, catheter | 11 | |
| | problems, and allergic reaction) | | |
| | | | |
When deciding to attend A&E, 37% of patients did so without recourse to any health professional. However, 63% had contacted their GP, the OOH service, 999 or NHS direct.
The GP Practice was opened when 54% of the respondents attended A&E. Of these respondents, 47% contacted their GP prior to attending. According to respondents, attendance could be reduced by quicker access to speak with a health care professional, improved education on self care and walk-in health centre facilities in Tidworth and Amesbury.
79% of the patients were aware of alternative services to A&E, and of these 65% felt they had sufficient information to use these services should the need arise.
65% of respondents also considered that it would be useful for Practices to contact patients after visiting A&E if the problem could have been handled in primary care.
SECTION 3: Communication
In this section, patients were asked about the channels of communication between Practices and patients as this area was direct and indirect raised throughout the initial Plain Talking meetings.
Communication from Patients to Practices
The method of communication depended on the service required. However, 63% of respondents preferred to contact their practice by telephone or call in person and 21% wished to use email.
Communication from Practices to patients
Again, the method of communication depended on the service required. However, 73% of respondents preferred to be contacted by telephone, 39% by SMS and 45% to be invited into the Practice. Adding messages to the right hand side of prescriptions or on websites was not popular.
Communicating about general practice information and campaigns
It was evident that Practices need to use a variety of communication mediums to inform patients about campaigns, e.g. flu, to ensure optimal access. Using posters in the Practice, emailing, SMS and writing were preferred.
When asked about the use of radio, on 35% listened to local radio, the most popular being Spire FM. However, 58% thought that having information about local health services announced on the radio would be useful.
Practice newsletters were popular with 86% of respondents stating they like to read them. The preferred method of receiving these was by email, closely followed by post, and then by collecting a copy from the Practice. Only 15% wished to access the newsletter from the website.
Just over half the respondents knew that their Practice had a website, and of these 42 patients (33%) had looked at the website. Of these patients, 90% had found the website useful, 75% stated it was easy to use, and 67% easy to find.
SECTION 4: Other
All respondents were asked to add any other comments. These have been categorised according to Practice:
Avon Valley Practice: No additional comments received
Barcroft Medical Practice: No additional comments received
Bourne Valley Practice : No additional comments received
Castle Practice: 5% of respondents would like to be able to book appointments online
Cross Plains Surgery: No additional comments received
St Melor House Surgery: No additional comments received
RECOMMENDATIONS
In order to improve the provision of local healthcare, the Practice Managers reviewed the results of the survey on 27th January 2012 and proposed the following recommendations to address the issues raised through the survey:
A&E attendances
1. To contact patients, if appropriate, following receipt of information about A&E attendance, to use alternative services should a similar problem arise again
2. To improve the depth and breadth of information provided to patients about self care and the use of A&E. This includes encouraging patients to contact their GP or OOH service prior to A&E attendance unless there is a life threatening accident or emergency.
Communication
1. To publish practice website information widely throughout the local area, including in local village / parish magazines.
2. To write and circulate a Practice Newsletter at least quarterly to all patients
3. To advertise the use of SMS for practice updates
4. To revise new patient registration forms to collect email data to distribute general practice information
5. To publicise GP telephone availability
Next steps
Please provide feedback about these recommendations to Heather Simpson by 28th February 2012 so that amendments can be made. Following receipt of feedback, a final report will be written and distributed to all patients.
Many thanks,
Heather Simpson
telephone: 01980 625 314
email: h.simpson2@nhs.net